Historyden
Historyden
  • Видео 232
  • Просмотров 2 815 031
Second Punic War - Battle of Utica and Battle of the Great Plains - 60
203 BC. 2 decisive battles turn the tide in Africa.
Complete Ancient Rome playlist: ruclips.net/video/_FVz_AmAtqQ/видео.html
Hey everyone! If you're enjoying the content on my channel and would like to support my work, consider making a donation. Your contributions help me continue creating quality videos, upgrade my equipment, and bring you even better content. Every donation, big or small, makes a huge difference and is greatly appreciated. By supporting the channel, you're directly helping to keep it going and growing. Thank you for being such an amazing community, and thank you in advance for your generosity!
Options for donating:
-You can donate by just clicking on one of my videos and s...
Просмотров: 1 061

Видео

Alexandria - One of the Greatest Cities of the Ancient World
Просмотров 55628 дней назад
Welcome to our exploration of the magnificent ancient city of Alexandria, one of the greatest cities of the Hellenistic world! Founded by Alexander the Great in 331 BC, Alexandria became a beacon of culture, knowledge, and innovation. In this video, we'll take you on a journey through the history of the city and the major sites. The Great Library of Alexandria: Discover the heart of ancient sch...
OJ Murder Trial Podcast - Part 1 (using some Google Earth)
Просмотров 31Месяц назад
OJ Murder Trial Podcast - Part 1 (using some Google Earth) 9:46 Where OJ and Nicole Meet 23:57 Mezzaluna 32:23 Nicole's house 36:08 Gate in the back alley - Use Google Earth to show where Mezzaluna restaurant was located and take a look at the Nicole Brown Simpson condo where she was murdered. Also use Google Earth to show where the Daisy was located where OJ and Nicole first met.
15 World War 2 Trivia Questions
Просмотров 1,4 тыс.Месяц назад
15 World War II Trivia Questions - Quiz Playlist: ruclips.net/p/PLZr2JvFQqLWRJKijYujHlBEz9aqrjasA6 Music from RUclips Audio Library: Parasail Lights Go Down Above Planets
15 Middle Ages Trivia Questions
Просмотров 205Месяц назад
15 Middle Ages Trivia Questions - Quiz Playlist: ruclips.net/p/PLZr2JvFQqLWRJKijYujHlBEz9aqrjasA6 Music from RUclips Audio Library: Parasail Lights Go Down Above Planets
Rambling a bit on why Carthage lost
Просмотров 674Месяц назад
Rambling a bit on why Carthage lost and don't feel like doing Zama Hey everyone! If you're enjoying the content on my channel and would like to support my work, consider making a donation. Your contributions help me continue creating quality videos, upgrade my equipment, and bring you even better content. Every donation, big or small, makes a huge difference and is greatly appreciated. By suppo...
Second Punic War - Siege of Utica - 59
Просмотров 517Месяц назад
204 BC. Scipio and his army lay siege to Utica. Complete Ancient Rome playlist: ruclips.net/video/_FVz_AmAtqQ/видео.html Hey everyone! If you're enjoying the content on my channel and would like to support my work, consider making a donation. Your contributions help me continue creating quality videos, upgrade my equipment, and bring you even better content. Every donation, big or small, makes ...
Second Punic War - Chaos in Locri - 58
Просмотров 506Месяц назад
205 BC. Romans and Carthaginians fight it out for control of Locri. Complete Ancient Rome playlist: ruclips.net/video/_FVz_AmAtqQ/видео.html
Channel Update
Просмотров 699Год назад
Channel Update
Day 37 of the 2022 Russian-Ukraine War - Any end in sight? - Podcast
Просмотров 7012 года назад
Day 37 of the 2022 Russian-Ukraine War - Any end in sight? - Podcast
Day 5 of the 2022 Russian invasion of Ukraine - Podcast
Просмотров 1 тыс.2 года назад
Day 5 of the 2022 Russian invasion of Ukraine - Podcast
What do Putin and Russia want in Ukraine? Is war upon us? - Podcast
Просмотров 1,2 тыс.2 года назад
What do Putin and Russia want in Ukraine? Is war upon us? - Podcast
The Crisis of the Third Century - Roman Empire is nearly ripped apart
Просмотров 9672 года назад
The Crisis of the Third Century - Roman Empire is nearly ripped apart
Alexander's Successors: Wars of the Diadochi
Просмотров 3,7 тыс.2 года назад
Alexander's Successors: Wars of the Diadochi -After Alexanders death his generals fight it out for control of the empire
The Battle of Mutina - The last chance for the Senate and Roman Republic - Podcast
Просмотров 7572 года назад
The Battle of Mutina - The last chance for the Senate and Roman Republic - Podcast
Are we at a tipping point in terms of technology and warfare? - Podcast
Просмотров 5652 года назад
Are we at a tipping point in terms of technology and warfare? - Podcast
Channel Update
Просмотров 5502 года назад
Channel Update
Second Punic War - Scipio in Rome - 57
Просмотров 2,3 тыс.2 года назад
Second Punic War - Scipio in Rome - 57
The Middle Ages - Belisarius takes control of Carthage - 15
Просмотров 1 тыс.2 года назад
The Middle Ages - Belisarius takes control of Carthage - 15
Second Punic War - Battle of Ilipa - 56
Просмотров 2,8 тыс.2 года назад
Second Punic War - Battle of Ilipa - 56
Ancient Egypt History - Sixth Dynasty - 09
Просмотров 1,7 тыс.2 года назад
Ancient Egypt History - Sixth Dynasty - 09
Channel Update
Просмотров 6522 года назад
Channel Update
Ancient Greek History - Philip increases the influence of Macedon - 50
Просмотров 2,2 тыс.2 года назад
Ancient Greek History - Philip increases the influence of Macedon - 50
My favorite 'modern' military historian: Theodore Ayrault Dodge
Просмотров 6933 года назад
My favorite 'modern' military historian: Theodore Ayrault Dodge
15 Ancient Greece Trivia Questions
Просмотров 1,3 тыс.3 года назад
15 Ancient Greece Trivia Questions
15 Ancient Rome Trivia Questions
Просмотров 2,2 тыс.3 года назад
15 Ancient Rome Trivia Questions
Let's test my knowledge of Roman History on Sporcle
Просмотров 6743 года назад
Let's test my knowledge of Roman History on Sporcle
Podcast - Additional commentary on Battle of the Metaurus
Просмотров 5073 года назад
Podcast - Additional commentary on Battle of the Metaurus
Second Punic War - Battle of the Metaurus - 55
Просмотров 3,9 тыс.3 года назад
Second Punic War - Battle of the Metaurus - 55
Trivia - Can you identify these figures from the American Civil War?
Просмотров 1 тыс.3 года назад
Trivia - Can you identify these figures from the American Civil War?

Комментарии

  • @Drutzie
    @Drutzie 8 дней назад

    WHAT ABOUT THE SPHNIX?

    • @Historyden
      @Historyden 3 дня назад

      I think I talk about it later on

  • @hollies4806
    @hollies4806 14 дней назад

    👍👍

  • @hollies4806
    @hollies4806 14 дней назад

    👍👍

  • @Dataism
    @Dataism 17 дней назад

    Yo New Historyden video just dropped!

  • @adecentcreatoryt
    @adecentcreatoryt 21 день назад

    W

  • @bernardrednix756
    @bernardrednix756 28 дней назад

    Its been a while

    • @Historyden
      @Historyden 28 дней назад

      It sure has and good to hear from you again

    • @bernardrednix756
      @bernardrednix756 28 дней назад

      @@Historyden been working a 12 hour job at a 24 hour convenience mart barely find the time

    • @Historyden
      @Historyden 28 дней назад

      @@bernardrednix756 Yeah time is always the problem

  • @skyfall9124
    @skyfall9124 29 дней назад

    Thanks! I love this series

  • @Zaeyrus
    @Zaeyrus Месяц назад

    Rolling rolling rolling....

  • @mikeevans96
    @mikeevans96 Месяц назад

    Scipio Africanus was like Julius Caesar in military genius ,but without the ego and ambition. Had he been around in Caesar's day, Caesar would have had a harder time than he did.

    • @Cowpitulate
      @Cowpitulate Месяц назад

      If they existed in the same time period Caesar would have overshadowed Scipio in a huge way. Scipio didn't attack Hannibal head on, he went after Carthage. Caesar on the other hand, took every challenge head on, he was an opportunist and also there wasn't anything he didn't try. He thought outside the box. Scipio followed the logical steps of war. His war in Africa is basically a set of steps. Take this to take that. He also had the backing of the state, reluctantly perhaps but Caesar for the most part done everything on his own. Again, think of the accomplishments. Think of the regions he went to, the circumstances for each event, the challenges. He fought a siege in Alexandria with a single Legion for the most part of a year. Logistically the feats he pulled off and the speed in which he done it show real true master class for planning and details. Caesar was as close as you can get to a true God of strategy. And most of those tactics were on the fly when he had to adapt, rather than being planned on in advance, step by step. I suppose it is subjective at the end of the day but tactically Caesar is in a league well beyond the reach of Scipio, however Scipio lived in a time when the Republic was still relatively new and there must have been many things Caesar benefited from because of time that Scipio would have been on the forefront of. So who knows.

    • @mikeevans96
      @mikeevans96 Месяц назад

      The republic was 300 years old at the time of Africanus. He didn't just follow the Roman rules for waging war. He used his head too. Read about his victory at Ilipa. That wasn't in any text book. And as far as defeating opponents, wouldn't you say Hannibal and his brothers was about as tough as anyone Caesar fought? The Romans certainly thought so. I'm not taking anything away from Caesar by saying that.

    • @Historyden
      @Historyden Месяц назад

      The other point I would make is the make up of the army itself. By the time we get to Caesar's period Roman consuls and generals are doing everything to keep their army loyal. They were loyal first to the general .. during Scipio's time the loyalty was to Rome first and foremost. I think if a Roman general ever attempted to march on Rome the army would have mutinied.

  • @Cowpitulate
    @Cowpitulate Месяц назад

    I am rewatching all the roman videos so i am at the start of the first punic war, hopefully by the time i catch up there isnt much waiting until the end. Absolutely love the content lately. Its soooooo good to have you back and creating. As many other people have said, you have a gift for doing lectures. Never boring. Always interesting and everything you cover is consumed without issue. Really great series. Hope there is many more videos to come in the roman and greek categories. And i hope you never lose the passion for creating these. Now more than ever we need people willing to educate us on the past as i think it is obvious there are those who wish to erase our past and modify it so we have no identity or icons. Keep it up mate. We are loving it. 😂

    • @Historyden
      @Historyden Месяц назад

      Well I can tell you just 2 left now and that is it - I am planning on doing a video of Hannibals activities after the war

    • @Cowpitulate
      @Cowpitulate Месяц назад

      @@Historyden I'm not gonna lie, i am sad it is coming to and end but where it goes from after the completion is obviously very interesting, you can choose to linger around this period or fast forward to all the better stand alone battles that leads to Sulla and then Caesar and Augustus and so on. I can understand how you don't wana get bogged down in a single series but do understand that you are one of the only channels that does go this deep. You give whole new perspectives to people getting into this sort of history and the exposure for some to the more detailed versions of these periods is in my opinion more essential than just grazing the surface.

    • @Historyden
      @Historyden Месяц назад

      @@Cowpitulate Probably will just stick to Livy and go right into the Second Macedonian War

    • @Cowpitulate
      @Cowpitulate 29 дней назад

      @@Historyden is this in relation to the alliance signed with carthage but never fully acted on? Or is it a while after the dust has settled?

    • @Historyden
      @Historyden 29 дней назад

      Yep the alliance then the start of the Second Macedonian War in 200 BC

  • @Insectoid_
    @Insectoid_ Месяц назад

    Roughs? Is that a roof? (I am not English)

    • @Historyden
      @Historyden Месяц назад

      oh can you give me a time stamp?

    • @Insectoid_
      @Insectoid_ Месяц назад

      @@Historyden it is roof. I asked an American friend from Florida and she pronounced it the same. I learnt in England. Since watching RUclips I am really noticing many differences. So example I always knew about herb having a silent H in America because of listening to rap music :) ciao

    • @Historyden
      @Historyden Месяц назад

      @@Insectoid_ How interesting .. my guess is that is a dialect thing. I live in the Midwest and there are many words pronounced differently in other parts of the country.

  • @johnpryke4992
    @johnpryke4992 Месяц назад

    Can't get enough of these videos!

  • @kelamullah1999
    @kelamullah1999 Месяц назад

    Do a part two plz. I'm glad to know that you share in my inconsistent work ethic.

    • @Historyden
      @Historyden Месяц назад

      LOL for sure I will do another one

  • @Cowpitulate
    @Cowpitulate Месяц назад

    Wow you are on a roll mate, past few videos have been fire! Maybe an ancient city series are on the cards?

    • @Historyden
      @Historyden Месяц назад

      Possibly!

    • @Historyden
      @Historyden Месяц назад

      Thinking about doing one on Persepolis

    • @Cowpitulate
      @Cowpitulate Месяц назад

      @@Historyden What is all this thinking, thinking delays things, from now on you get an idea and you do it. You cannot fail with this channel. Some content is hit or miss but better to be creating than thinking about it.

    • @Historyden
      @Historyden Месяц назад

      @@Cowpitulate Mostly its a time thing for me .. if I had more time I could do tons more

    • @remimk
      @remimk 29 дней назад

      I second this

  • @hardsystem9522
    @hardsystem9522 Месяц назад

    yes of course read the book from Malala there it is writte: Achilles left with the Atreidai, bringing his own army of 3000 of the men known then as Myrmidons but known now as Bulgars, - SLAVS do you actually understand what SLAVS means? In the so called slavic languages, SLAV means GLORY, and the Alexander Makedonski acutally wanted to beat the thrace people but he could not and he decided to offer them a money to be from his army and they accepted. He called them the SLAVs, the GLORIOUS because they were fighting very brave... please read old good real resources to no read new history because the new resources are overwriten from the new big countries in order to somehow boost their history and confidence... the real historians they now this prety well.... there are many old authors saying that the Bulgarians are the thracian tribe Mysians.. etc.. or the Peonites ... there are different sources but for sure Bulgaria is the oldest country in Europa.. check the map of Jerome, the so call Map of Turnai - this author lived in 400 year and he draw on his map Mysia here is Bulgaria. Find the map in Google. I do not care what is accepted in the other countries the truth is another... of course the people who are not well informed like you will talk information which is not true.. but now you know a bit more about it. If you are intelligent person you will go and read more about it and next time you wont spread fake information. :) What I wrote is not what I think but what authors 1500 years ago wrote about Bulgaria :)

  • @fenrirthedreadwolf3448
    @fenrirthedreadwolf3448 Месяц назад

    This one of the best history channals out there

  • @bostonteapartycrasher
    @bostonteapartycrasher Месяц назад

    IDK if you're familiar with Dota 2 at all, but there was an infamous pro match in which the carry player for team LGD, Rabbit, had an unbelievable, flawless performance. He finished the match with a kill/death score of 17/0 but still lost the game. This spawned the unofficial reward called the "rabbit award" for losing despite an incredible performance. It always reminds me of Hannibal. Hannibal made the most spectacular entrance of any invasion force in history. He handed the Romans their worst defeat ever at Trebia. He made another spectacular march, this time through an impassable swamp. He sprung the largest, most successful ambush in history at Trasimene. He escaped an utterly hopeless situation completely unscathed at Ager Falernus. Then, to top it all off, he scored the greatest battlefield victory of all time at Cannae. Hannibal must have been thinking he had just completed the most perfectly executed military campaign in history. Now it's time to go home and forever be known as the greatest general who ever lived. I can't imagine how pissed he must have been when the Romans were just like, "Nope!"

    • @Historyden
      @Historyden Месяц назад

      I have actually heard of Dota 2. Yeah the Hannibal situation always amazes me .. few city states could have survived that type of onslaught and still kept raising new legions

  • @captainmctavish4168
    @captainmctavish4168 Месяц назад

    Loved your series, can you make similar series on Spartacus?

    • @Historyden
      @Historyden Месяц назад

      eventually for sure

    • @captainmctavish4168
      @captainmctavish4168 Месяц назад

      @@Historyden to quote star wars the rogue one, "rebellions are built on hope"

  • @huwhitecavebeast1972
    @huwhitecavebeast1972 Месяц назад

    Good good, I didn't know about 5 of these.

  • @SharanGarlapati-yh4bt
    @SharanGarlapati-yh4bt Месяц назад

    Egregious Roman L (they should've had Fabius in charge).

  • @AbbeyRoadkill1
    @AbbeyRoadkill1 Месяц назад

    The only question I got wrong was the one about the last Merovingian king. I really should've missed a few more but I got lucky with a couple of blind guesses.

    • @Historyden
      @Historyden Месяц назад

      That was definitely a hard one

  • @HarosOfStyx
    @HarosOfStyx Месяц назад

    So here is what i got: 1. Leo I (wrong. Yikes. That's embarassing) 2. Vandals (wrong. I could have sworn i knew that one.) 3. Andrew (wrong. I've barely read anything on the clergy of the heretical religions, so.) 4. Battle of Hastings (correct. Yah! i got one correct lol) 5. Gregory I (correct. I'm surprised i knew that one) 6. Persian (wrong. Kurdish?! really? hmm) 7. False. (correct. For some reason, I know the heirarchy or aristocracts, royals, etc lol) 8. 845. (Correct. No idea how i rememebr that one) 9. England (correct. It has to be since it's a hop, skip, and jump away from their lands) 10. China. (correct. Also, why have Turkey on the list when it didn't even exist until a few centuries ago? Turks came from upper China. oO They're a Mongol race.) 11. Eleanor of Aquitaine. (correct. I'm happy I rememebred that one lol) 12. Johannes Gutenberg (correct. If i had made a mistake with that, i should have burnt all my books) 13. Dagobert III (wrong. But iwas leaning toward Childeric III) 14. El Sid (wrong. Yikes. I should have known the correct answer) 15. Genoa (correct. That was a tricky one.) So, 9/15 correct. Surprising. I believe i would have had a lot more wrong.

    • @Historyden
      @Historyden Месяц назад

      I think the Saladin was the hardest one ... these are harder trivia videos so anything above 60pct is pretty good

  • @silentflight1
    @silentflight1 Месяц назад

    the ones I got wrong (1,3,7,14). but some of the correct answers were flukes(like Egypt declaring war)

    • @Historyden
      @Historyden Месяц назад

      That was probably the hardest one because they declared war right at the end of the war

  • @HarosOfStyx
    @HarosOfStyx Месяц назад

    So these are what i chose: 1. Neptune (which was wrong) 2. Oberekommando des Heeres (wrong. So close on that one lol) 3. Patton (correct. Thank God i could still remember that one) 4. Rommel (obviously wrong) 5. Zhukov (correct) 6. Himmel (Correct) 7. Heinrici (correct) 8. Georgia (correct) 9. Hump (correct) 10. Austria (correct. if i had gottent that one wrong i should have never shown my face again lol) 11. Soviet Union (wrong. Considering the research they did, i should never have gotten it wrong) 12. HMS King George V (correct. I wasn't sure though, i was also leaning toward Hood) 13. True. (correct) 14. USS Indianapolis. (correct. I kind of laughed at USS Enterprise since there's no way it could have been it since it's in a museum if I'm not mistaken. 15. Munich (wrong. Yikes, ashamed i got that one wrong) So, final score is: 10/15 correct.

    • @Historyden
      @Historyden Месяц назад

      That is pretty good I thought 2, 11, 15 were the hardest and I wonder how many people got 9 correct

  • @wheel631
    @wheel631 Месяц назад

    the final one got me!!

  • @cedrep
    @cedrep Месяц назад

    5 errors and 2 lucky ones where I was correct by picking a random answer (hello Saladin). That was fun, got to check about Arianism now

    • @Historyden
      @Historyden Месяц назад

      That was undoubtedly the hardest one

  • @bishop6218
    @bishop6218 Месяц назад

    Rome had so many good generals because Hannibal already killed most of the bad ones 😂

    • @Historyden
      @Historyden Месяц назад

      LOL true!

    • @brucetucker4847
      @brucetucker4847 Месяц назад

      At Cannae he killed the good one and the foolish one survived.

  • @blinkyrem
    @blinkyrem Месяц назад

    13/15, popes and archbishops got me!

    • @Historyden
      @Historyden Месяц назад

      That was not an easy one

  • @beepboop204
    @beepboop204 Месяц назад

  • @Cowpitulate
    @Cowpitulate Месяц назад

    I'm loving the new format for some videos where you dive deeper into random things here or there. The last video summarizing Hannibal was really good too, some times you forget just how much content has been covered so it's good to take a step back and analyse things, would be good to get something similar when you talk about characters such as Sulla, Caesar, Augustus, Alexander and Phillip II. Really cannot wait to see all the new content you produce now going forward.

  • @williamarthur4801
    @williamarthur4801 Месяц назад

    Got most right, have to go and have a look at German tribes and 'Arianism', I had no idea they had a view on the subject, which could make them better informed on their faith than many today. 🙄🙄

    • @Historyden
      @Historyden Месяц назад

      The Arian missions were able to get up there around the time it was declared heresy by the Council of Nicaea

  • @Historyden
    @Historyden Месяц назад

    Let me know your scores - a couple of those questions I was grinning when I was creating them.

    • @wheel631
      @wheel631 Месяц назад

      13/15 - The Merovingian king and Saladin ones got me

  • @captainmctavish4168
    @captainmctavish4168 Месяц назад

    The return of the king

  • @skyfall9124
    @skyfall9124 Месяц назад

    Thanks!

  • @skyfall9124
    @skyfall9124 Месяц назад

    The Carthaginian senate also lacked vision. Later Cato would say "Carthago delenda est" after each oration and Carthage was destroyed. Please keep going. Zama or bust! jk Cheers

    • @Historyden
      @Historyden Месяц назад

      Oh yeah that is one of the most epic lines in Roman history!

  • @dontbetrippin4575
    @dontbetrippin4575 Месяц назад

    how did YT not reccomend me this? welcome back

    • @Historyden
      @Historyden Месяц назад

      They probably don't like me lol

  • @dontbetrippin4575
    @dontbetrippin4575 Месяц назад

    Boy ain't no way boy... boy ain't no way boy...

  • @VasileIuga
    @VasileIuga Месяц назад

    Rome had a great patriarchal and legal culture creating rarely idiots but mostly great men among nobility early on. Hannibal was an exception.

    • @Historyden
      @Historyden Месяц назад

      Ohhhh yeah that patriarchal system was something

  • @Zaeyrus
    @Zaeyrus Месяц назад

    Hannibal Barca, son of Hamilcar, was the best roman general! Change my mind :P Ok, ok, jokes a side, Hannibal defeated Rome in every battle up until the last one, he was closest to bringing Rome down and he failed. And as the saying goes, "what doesn't kill you makes you stronger" therefore Hannibal was the best Roman general

    • @Historyden
      @Historyden Месяц назад

      Yeah he changed Rome and warfare forever

  • @huwhitecavebeast1972
    @huwhitecavebeast1972 Месяц назад

    I think Alexander was as good as Hannibal, or possibly better. His leadership style was different from Hannibal's, but just as effective. I guess I would say Hannibal was probably a more shrewd tactician, but Alexander was a greater warrior and reader of men. Hannibal's lesser skill in reading men cost him dearly.

    • @Historyden
      @Historyden Месяц назад

      I should be getting to him soon in my Greek series - always love reading Arrian

    • @Cowpitulate
      @Cowpitulate Месяц назад

      @@Historyden Have you ever read the Landmark series for Alexander by Arrian? They also have a few books on Thucydides, Xenophon and Herodotus. Really is a great book series.

    • @Historyden
      @Historyden Месяц назад

      @@Cowpitulate I have my copies of Arrian but I might have to check that out in terms of Landmark

    • @huwhitecavebeast1972
      @huwhitecavebeast1972 Месяц назад

      @@Cowpitulate The Anabasis of Cyrus is an amazing read.

    • @Cowpitulate
      @Cowpitulate Месяц назад

      @@Historyden They are hard to get New and will set you back a fair amount but the Landmark series on Alexander is absolutely astounding. The depth that they go into, especially with the maps, it is unreal. Same goes for the Caesar book. A lot of people don't enjoy reading the logistical tallies that Caesar would constantly write down but in that way i think he is one of the greats. And i know it's very easy to say Caesar was lying and discount his logistics chronology but the man was almost autistic in this manner, i don't think he lied about the tallies even in men injured or killed. I think it is just very easy to demonize the man who destroyed the power of the senatorial families. Anyway, the Landmark series covers the Peloponnesian war from Thucydides and Xenophon in excruciatingly deep detail, it also covers the march of the 10,000, a lot of Herodotus, Caesar and Alexander. And i think they are still working on a few more books due out next year. Definitely worth a read if you love those periods.

  • @huwhitecavebeast1972
    @huwhitecavebeast1972 Месяц назад

    Yeah, I thought The Carthagians were foolish not to support Hannibal. But Hannibal should have taken Rome itself while he had the chance.

    • @Historyden
      @Historyden Месяц назад

      Especially the amount of soldiers they provided to Gisco

    • @Historyden
      @Historyden Месяц назад

      If you're talking about the road being open after Cannae? It certainly was and many since have debated why he didn't .. I don't think he brought siege equipment with him maybe that would have been difficult over the Alps.

    • @Lo-tf6qt
      @Lo-tf6qt Месяц назад

      @@Historyden Personally I think that Hannibal could've never taken Rome after Cannae, since Rome itself had become extremely fortified by this point and even if he did besiege Rome, he'd be taking away his biggest advantage which was out-manoeuvring Rome's legions and keeping his army supplied by raiding the countryside. (Plus the Celts don't seem like the kind of soldiers who'd be willing to sit down and wait for Rome to surrender after a long siege) If Hannibal was given more support from Carthage I feel like he could've had a very good chance of taking on Rome

  • @Bruh___452
    @Bruh___452 Месяц назад

    I didn’t finish watching this series yet, but It is probably one of the best series I found on this platform, because it went into detail of what happened in Italy after Cannae. Instead of just saying that “the Romans started using a war of attrition, and attacked were Hannibal wasn’t”.

    • @Historyden
      @Historyden Месяц назад

      So much more to the war than that battle for sure

  • @johnpryke4992
    @johnpryke4992 Месяц назад

    Its so hard to learn just how neglected Hannibal was, I guess they thought he will make do....🤦

    • @Historyden
      @Historyden Месяц назад

      I hear Netflix is either doing a series on him or a movie - should be interesting

  • @Cowpitulate
    @Cowpitulate Месяц назад

    It sort of reminds me of Athens during the Great Peloponnesian War, in your other series. When Athens charged 6 Generals for failing to rescue survivors. I mean even if this was a thing, they were at war and the idea of offing your leaders during wartime is unbelievable. Same thing seems to be happening here in which Hannibal would have won the war outright if Carthage had halted its divisive government, pulled together and had worked with Hannibal to give him supplies and reinforcements. Instead those in power did everything they could to sabotage Hannibal and while they had a schism within their government. Rome on the other hand was strong and was slowly becoming more and more unified in its war effort. Assisting and doing what ever was needed to win. One side is unified and driven towards one single goal, the other, disjointed and seeking to undermine its political rivals, despite the fact that they are at war.

    • @Historyden
      @Historyden Месяц назад

      ohhhh yeah that is a great point - that was lunacy on a scale that it almost immeasurable ROFL

    • @huwhitecavebeast1972
      @huwhitecavebeast1972 Месяц назад

      Accurate. I thought the same thing about the Athenians killing their generals who just won a battle while they are in the middle of a war. Insane! A serious, for all the marbles kind of war, and they did that.

    • @brucetucker4847
      @brucetucker4847 Месяц назад

      You have to look at things from the actors' POV, though. The chief aim of the Carthaginian government wasn't to defeat Rome, it was to extend and cement their power as a class, both internally and externally. A victory over Rome that left the ruling class' power subservient to an effective military monarchy was no victory at all. Rome managed to avoid that internal conflict in the Punic Wars, but it definitely became a major factor in the succeeding 200 years or so. And it is extremely common in history. This is why I dispute that Hannibal was a military leader comparable to Caesar, Alexander, or Napoleon. He was fantastic on the battlefield but had a somewhat dim grasp of the political situation and how that had to affect both his methods and his grand strategic goals.

  • @johnpryke4992
    @johnpryke4992 Месяц назад

    Another excellent video!

  • @zeusnitch
    @zeusnitch Месяц назад

    Good to see you back!

  • @Zaeyrus
    @Zaeyrus Месяц назад

    True to his word! Let's keep the momentum going ;)

    • @Historyden
      @Historyden Месяц назад

      I might even have another out tomorrow lol

  • @phamxuanthai1
    @phamxuanthai1 Месяц назад

    Holy molly, where the hell have you been my man, it's been a long time and suddenly you drop 2 videos in quick succession, thank you thank you very much

    • @Historyden
      @Historyden Месяц назад

      thx i decided to surprise you guys

  • @alessandropoma6049
    @alessandropoma6049 Месяц назад

    Good, good, good 🎉

  • @kennethknoppik5408
    @kennethknoppik5408 Месяц назад

    Glad to see you back. I was worried about you😊

    • @Historyden
      @Historyden Месяц назад

      I remember you and good to hear from you again. I am doing well and hope to get some more content out there over the summer ..

    • @kennethknoppik5408
      @kennethknoppik5408 Месяц назад

      @@Historyden nice, looking forward to that